Halloween Coloring Contest
The Kingman Daily Miner Logo
Trusted local news leader for Kingman, Arizona & Mohave County
6:29 AM Mon, Oct. 15th

McGee found guilty of murder

KINGMAN - It took close to three and a half hours for a jury of Jack Darrell McGee's peers to find him not only guilty of murder, but also sane at the time.

Seven men and five women each confirmed the first-degree murder verdict for the Golden Valley man, when polled by defense attorney Carlene Lacy.

McGee, 24, was found guilty of the first-degree murder of Billy Dewayne Carlton Jr., 26, of Golden Valley, guilty of aggravated assault on Billy Dewayne Carlton Sr. and Jim Neal McGee, guilty of drive-by shooting, and guilty of discharging a firearm at a residence.

The deceased victim's family hugged and cried while the verdict was being read.

Upon the jury's dismissal, the family thanked each juror for coming to a guilty verdict.

On the first-degree murder charge, McGee faces life in prison with the possibility of parole in 25 years or natural life in prison.

On the dangerous Class 3 felony aggravated assaults, he faces a maximum of 15 years on each charge.

On the dangerous Class 2 felony drive-by shooting and discharging a firearm at a residence, McGee faces a maximum of 21 years on each charge.

Mohave County Judge James E. Chavez set judgment and sentencing for 9:30 a.m. on July 9.

Before the foreman of the jury delivered the verdict, Chavez addressed the jurors, explaining their decision in this case was more difficult than most cases due to the insanity defense.

"I put this in the hard range because it's rare to have this kind of case in Mohave County," Chavez said.

During the weeklong trial, prosecutor Greg McPhillips presented evidence that on Oct. 4, 2005, McGee drove to the residence in the 5700 block of Abrigo Drive, and briefly talked to the victim before shooting him in the heart and leg, killing him.

McGee then opened fire on Carlton Sr. and Jim McGee, who were also in the yard at the time.

Firing 18 rounds and reloading a clip into his gun after shooting Carlton Jr., Jack McGee hit Jim McGee in the wrist and elbow, missing Carlton Sr.

Jack McGee then left the scene, driving to Davis Dam to dispose of the gun used in the shooting, but still kept his other gun in his possession. Bullhead City Police stopped McGee near the dam.

McGee later admitted to investigators he dumped the gun used in the incident over the dam.

During the interview, McGee also admitted to shooting at the three men, as well as shooting at a residence he thought Carlton Jr. was at on July 15, 2005.

McGee also told detectives he killed Carlton Jr. because voices in his heard told him to do it. That admission is what Lacy argued during the trial.

Lacy said that as an alleged paranoid schizophrenic, McGee imagined an elaborate gang rape that he thought was real.

She added McGee said he heard voices telling him he must kill Carlton Jr., who he imagined was one of the individuals involved with the rape.

She didn't dispute McGee's guilt, but rather his sanity.

The jurors did not agree with the defense, choosing to find McGee guilty instead of guilty but insane.