#RedforEd surrenders; teachers should be back at work Thursday
PHOENIX - Unable to convince Republicans to provide more cash for K-12 education, members of the #RedForEd movement told members late Tuesday to go back to work.
But not until Thursday. And not until lawmakers give final approval to the budget and teacher pay plan, now scheduled for later today.
Noah Karvelis, one of the organizers of Arizona Educators United, said the movement - and the strike that began this past Thursday - already has scored several key victories.
He said the Republican-controlled Legislature agreed last month to extend the 0.6-cent sales tax for education beyond its 2020 expiration date. That was not something that was even on Gov. Doug Ducey's agenda when the session started in January.
More significant, Ducey has agreed to an average 9 percent pay hike for teachers for the coming school year, with a 5 percent increase the following year and an identical increase the year after that. By contrast, the budget the governor presented to lawmakers included just a one-time 1 percent increase.
Karvelis said the budget still leaves the #RedForEd movement far short of its original goals.
But he said that it has now become obvious that this is the best educators will get, at least this year.
That means it's time for teachers to return to classes - and their students - and begin work on the rest of the agenda. That includes supporting an initiative to raise $690 million through a surcharge on the state's highest wage earners in dedicated dollars for education, money that lawmakers cannot take away the next time there's a recession.
What also may be on the table, Karvelis said, is working to change the makeup of the Legislature - and perhaps even the governor's office.
"We've been so involved in just getting point right now that we haven't had a second to even catch our breath and think about that right now,'' he said. "But I guarantee you there are a lot of people walking around down here (at the Capitol) in red every single day, looking at themselves in the mirror and saying, 'If they can't get it done, I'll get it done.'''
For the moment, though, this is it.
"One of the deciding factors is that the Legislature has gone not as far as they're able to go, but as far as they're willing to go,'' he said. "That realization is crystal clear to everybody here who's been in there, trying to make their voice heard.''
Most notably missing from what lawmakers are set to vote on today, at least from the perspective of the educators, is their demand that funding be restored to 2008 levels. In fact, legislative budget staffers acknowledged Tuesday that, even with all the money the governor says the plan will put into K-12 education, per-student funding on an inflation-adjusted basis will still be less by 2021 than it was in 2008.
That is significant because one of the key demands of the #RedForEd movement is to bring state aid back to where it was a decade ago.
More than pay is at issue. During hearings occurring Tuesday even as the decision to go back was being announced, a parade of teachers told lawmakers about the effects of funding shortfalls, including the lack of funds for basic supplies and schools in disrepair.
They also fault Ducey and Republicans for the plan not providing dollars for support staff. Ducey said the $100 million he is restoring in additional district assistance comes with sufficient flexibility for school districts to use some - or all - of that for those employees.
But those dollars - and a lot more - used to be given to schools automatically for things like computers, books, buses and minor repairs. But those funds were raided during the recession, with Ducey himself taking $117 million from that account his first year in office to balance the state's books and make good on a promise of a tax cut.
Rep. David Livingston, R-Peoria, was not bothered by the finding that state aid to schools will remain below 2008 levels. He called that a "high-water mark'' for education dollars, saying it does not represent historic funding.
And there was something else in the the demand of the educators: No new tax cuts until per-pupil funding in Arizona reaches the national average.
There's a long way to get to that point, with legislative budget staffers pegging state aid now at $4,760. And even with local dollars, the figure reaches only about $8,500, at least $2,000 below the national average.
Yet the budget does include a tax break for retired military, exempting more of their pensions from state income taxes.
Gubernatorial press aide Daniel Scarpinato minimized the effects of the walkout. He noted that Ducey announced his teacher pay plan on April 12, a week before the vote by Arizona Educators United and the Arizona Education Association to strike.
But he conceded that the #RedForEd movement, started in early March after West Virginia teachers went on strike and got a 5 percent raise, had made a strong difference. It crystallized public support, with demonstrations and "walk-ins'' at public schools featuring perhaps 100,000 teachers and parents marching to show support for more funding for education.
So radical was Ducey's change of heart that just two days before that announcement, Ducey had dismissed the #RedForEd movement as "political theater,'' reaffirming his plan to give teachers just a 1 percent raise.
"The governor has listened,'' Scarpinato said Tuesday. "He's been impressed with the teachers.''
That pressure also also resulted in Ducey agreeing to meet with teachers - though pointedly not with either Karvelis or AEA President Joe Thomas.